Applications deferred from previous
meetings
Blank page
APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETING
ITEM NO 1
APPLIC NO Z/2004/0451/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Patton Group
APPLIC ADDRESS Greenmount House, Woodside
Industrial Estate,
BT42 4PT
LOCATION
PROPOSAL Mixed use development forming the
headquarters for The Boys' and Girls'
clubs N.I. incorporating cafe
and pontoon on water, offices,
conference/exhibition and rehearsal space,
training rooms and residential
ac
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Refusal
1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH8 of the
Department's Planning Policy Statement 6:
Planning, Archaeology
and the Built Heritage in that the
of the Planning (NI) Order
1991 and the proposed alterations would,
if permitted, detract from
its architectural/historic
integrity by reason of its detailed design which is out of keeping with
the architectural form,
design, character of the building in terms of scale, form, proportions
and alignment.
2 The proposal is contrary
to Policy BH11 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6:
Planning, Archaeology
and the Built Heritage in that the development would, if permitted,
adversely affect the setting of a
structure listed under Article 42 of the Planning (NI) Order
1991 [the
structure in terms of
scale, form, massing, proportions,
height, and alignment. The proposal
would also adversely impact on
the amenity of neighbouring properties due to
dominance and
overshadowing.
3 Deferred for deputation from applicant.
4 Opinion remains to refuse.
ITEM
NO 2
APPLIC NO Z/2004/0607/LB Listed Building Date Valid
APPLICANT The Patton Group
APPLIC ADDRESS Greenmount House, Woodside
industrial Estate,
BT42 4PT
LOCATION
PROPOSAL Alterations to existing wall to form
pedestrian access
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Refusal
1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH8 of the
Department's Planning Policy Statement 6:
Planning, Archaeology
and the Built Heritage in that the
of the Planning (NI) Order
1991 and the proposed alterations would,
if permitted, detract from
its architectural/historic
integrity by reason of its detailed design which is out of keeping with
the architectural form,
design, character of the building in terms of scale, form, proportions
and alignment.
2 Deferred for deputation
from applicant.
3 Opinion remains to refuse.
ITEM NO 3
APPLIC NO Z/2008/0058/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Andrews
APPLIC ADDRESS C/o Agent McCann Moore
Architects,
LOCATION 30 Castlehill
Park, Ballycloghan,
PROPOSAL Erection of a detached 2 storey house to
the side garden of 30 Castlehill Park
with new access formed onto
REPRESENTATION 16 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Approval
1 Deferred by Cllr.Rodgers,
Cllr Empey and Cllr Long for office meeting. - 17/04/09
2 Opinion remains to approve.
3
ITEM NO
4
APPLIC NO Z/2008/0489/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Brackhill Ltd
APPLIC ADDRESS C/o Alan Bennett
Architects,
2GZ
LOCATION 135 Shandon Park, Knock,
PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and
replacement with 4no detached dwellings
and garages.
REPRESENTATION 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Approval
1 Deferred by Councillor
Long for office meeting.
2 Opinion remains to approve.
ITEM NO 5
APPLIC NO Z/2008/1723/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Mr Robert Arthur
APPLIC ADDRESS 23 Glendarragh Mews,
LOCATION 28 Station Road, Strandtown,
PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 5
apartments including extension and
alterations
REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Approval
1 Deferred by Councillor
Long for office meeting.
2 Opinion remains to approve.
ITEM
NO 6
APPLIC NO Z/2008/1947/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Leisart Ltd
APPLIC ADDRESS
LOCATION Orpen Shopping Centre, Unit
5, Upper Lisburn Road.Belfast
PROPOSAL Change of use from retail to hot food bar
REPRESENTATION 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Approval
1 Deferred by Cllr Niall
Kelly, Cllr Mc Carthy for
office meeting -
2 Opinion remains to approve.
ITEM NO 7
APPLIC NO Z/2008/2134/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Mr A Rooney
APPLIC ADDRESS
LOCATION 39-41 Falls Road, Edenderry,
PROPOSAL Demolition of existing premises &
erection of 2 No. 1 bedroom & 18 No. 2
bedroom apartments and 2 No.
retail units [amended scheme].
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Refusal
1 The proposal is contrary to Planning Policy
Statement 1 and Policy QD1 of the Department's
Planning Policy Statement
7 'Quality Residential Environments' in that it has not been
demonstrated that the development
would create a quality and sustainable residential
environment. The proposed development would if permitted,
cause unacceptable damage to
the local character of an
established residential area by reason of overdevelopment of the
site, and being out of
keeping with the character and appearance of the local area by virtue of
it’s siting, layout, form, scale, massing, height, design and
lack of private open/amenity space.
2 Deferred by Councillor F McCann for office meeting.
3 Opinion remains to refuse.
ITEM
NO 8
APPLIC NO Z/2009/0138/A Advertisement Date Valid
APPLICANT Reavy & Co Solicitors
APPLIC ADDRESS 22 The Diamond, Rathcoole,
LOCATION Between the first floor and second floor
windows of
BT1 4QN
PROPOSAL Erection of electronic sign.
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Refusal
1 The proposal is contrary to Policy AD1 of
Planning Policy Statement 17 "Control of Outdoor
Advertisements" in
that the proposal if permitted, would harm the visual amenity and the
character and appearance of the
area due to inappropriate siting on the host
building, scale
and proportions which would
set an undesirable precedent for further similar signage,
resulting in further harm to the
character of the area.
2 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH13 of the
Department's Planning Policy Statement 6:
Planning, Archaeology
and the Built Heritage in that the site lies within the Belfast City Centre
Conservation Area and
the sign would, if permitted, adversely affect its appearance and
detract from the character of
the building upon which it is to be displayed by reason of its
inappropriate location which is
unduly prominent and the use of an inappropriate means of
illumination.
3 Deferred by Councillor Patterson for office meeting.
4 Opinion remains to refuse.
ITEM
NO 9
APPLIC NO Z/2009/0220/F Full Date Valid
APPLICANT Mr I Mc Millan
APPLIC ADDRESS
LOCATION Land north of
PROPOSAL Erection of 4No. semi
detached dwellings
REPRESENTATION 14 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Refusal
1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the
Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality
residential
environments in that in that it would if approved cause unacceptable damage to
the
residential amenity
through overlooking and consequent loss of privacy to neighbouring
residents.
2 The proposal is contrary
to Policy OS1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 8: Open
Space, Sport and Outdoor
Recreation in that it would, if permitted, result in the loss of an area
of existing open space of
public value.
3 Deferred by Councillor
Rodway.
4 Opinion remains to refuse.
ITEM NO 10
APPLIC NO Z/2009/0241/A Advertisement Date Valid
APPLICANT Cheque Cashpoint
APPLIC ADDRESS
LOCATION
PROPOSAL Erection of shop fascia sign.
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Consent
1 Deferred By Cllr. Sir Reg. Empey for office
meeting.
2 Change of opinion to approve - Temporary consent
for 3 years.
ITEM
NO 11
APPLIC NO Z/2009/0246/LB Listed Building Date Valid
APPLICANT Cheque Cashpoint
APPLIC ADDRESS
LOCATION
PROPOSAL Erection of shop sign.
REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions
OPINION Consent
1 Deferred by Cllr. Sir
Reg. Empey for office meeting.
2 Change of opinion to approve - Temporary consent
for 3 years.